If you have glanced at a screen this week, you could be forgiven for thinking the sky is falling. The S&P 500 has dropped three days running, Nvidia has lost its founder, and Washington has put new limits on where AI chips can be sold. Alfred E. Neuman had a line for moments like this, and I have borrowed most of it for the title.

I spent enough hours flying in cloud to learn that what you feel and what the instruments say are often two different things. So before anyone reaches for the ripcord, let’s read the panel. There are three gauges I want to walk you through.

1. The fear gauge is not afraid

The VIX is the closest thing Wall Street has to a fear gauge. The Chicago Board Options Exchange introduced it in 1993, and it measures one thing: what investors are paying, right now, for 30 days of insurance on the S&P 500. When people are frightened they pay up for protection, and the number rises.

A handy rule of thumb: divide the VIX by 16 and you get the daily move the market is braced for. Over its history the VIX has averaged somewhere around 19 or 20, which works out to a bit more than 1% a day.

Now, here is what panic looks like. In November 2008 the VIX closed at 80.86. In March 2020, with the world shutting down, it closed at 82.69, the highest on record. In the tariff scare of April 2025 it closed above 52.

Monday night it closed at about 23. On November 5, the worst day for stocks since that April, it got to about 28. That is a market paying a little more for its insurance. It is not a market that cannot find an insurer.

The indexes tell the same story. The S&P 500 is roughly 5% below its October record. The Nasdaq, where the AI names live, is off about 11%. Uncomfortable, yes. Disorderly, no.

2. AI: the engine, and the governor

I have said it before and I will say it again: I am a strong supporter of AI. It is the most important economic story of my career, and the numbers are staggering. The four largest cloud companies alone have guided to roughly $730 billion of capital spending this year. Barclays expects the hyperscalers to reach $1.3 trillion next year.

That money does not stay in Silicon Valley. It pays electricians, pipefitters, concrete crews and utility linemen, and it has been holding up a good share of this economy and this stock market.

But trees do not grow to the sky. Citrini Research, a widely read shop, published a piece this month arguing that we have reached peak growth in AI spending. Their arithmetic is simple: to double the spending again, the revenue coming back would have to be measured in trillions, and they do not see it. Note the wording. Nobody serious is saying the spending stops. They are saying the rate of climb is flattening, and stocks priced for a steep climb do not care for level flight.

Then there is Nvidia. Jensen Huang resigned last Thursday amid an internal investigation, and the CFO, Colette Kress, is running the company for now. On Monday the Commerce Department added license requirements for advanced chip sales to five more countries. A company worth nearly $6 trillion in early October has since given up about a third of that, and it reports earnings tonight.

When the standard-bearer stumbles, every board about to approve a data center budget has a fresh reason to ask for another month. That is how the Nvidia matter could turn a slower climb into a pause. It may not. But it is a reasonable thing to worry about, and reasonable worry is not panic.

3. Ten years of tailwind

Here is the gauge I have been watching longest. Over the ten years through October, the S&P 500 returned about 15% a year with dividends reinvested. Over the last hundred years the figure is closer to 10%.

Five points a year does not sound like much until you compound it. At 10%, $100,000 becomes about $260,000 in a decade. At 15% it becomes about $400,000. We have all been flying with a tailwind and some of us have started to think it was our airspeed.

What has it done to prices? The Shiller P/E, which compares stock prices to ten years of earnings, sits near 39. Its long-run median is under 17, and it has been higher than today in only about 2% of all months since 1881. Meanwhile the ten-year Treasury pays about 5.1%, so stocks have real competition for the first time in a long while.

A market priced this way has already been paid for above-average earnings growth. My question is the one I keep asking: where is that growth going to come from? If AI spending is flattening, the answer got harder this month. I do not think the next ten years look like the last ten.

So, what, me panic?

No. And I do not think you should either.

Put the three gauges together. Fear is elevated but ordinary. The industry that led us up is slowing, not collapsing. And prices were high enough that some giving back was owed. If this turns into a bear market, it has every appearance of being the ordinary, run-of-the-mill kind, the kind that comes around every few years and that every long-term investor has lived through before.

Here is the part I most want you to hear. An orderly market is a gift. In a panic you sell what you can, at whatever price you are offered. In an orderly decline there are buyers for everything, at fair prices, every day. You get to choose.

So use it. Trim what has grown too large. Trade up in quality. And for those of you in the higher brackets, look hard at tax-free municipal income, which I believe is where a good deal of this money ought to go.

One caution on the buying side. Do not buy a fallen stock on the assumption that the baby has been thrown out with the bathwater. In some cases it has. In others you are looking at a good old-fashioned rerating. As I wrote in my last missive, a stock that goes from 50 times earnings to 25 times has been cut in half without the business missing a beat, and nothing says it has to go back. Cheaper than last month is not the same thing as cheap.

If you would like to walk through your own panel, call me. That is what the right seat is for.

Let me be blunt: I am still hustling to grow KWM. The firm celebrated its tenth anniversary yesterday, and after nearly forty years in the business, I am finding more fun and satisfaction in this work than I ever have. Perhaps you, or someone you know, are a touch over your skis right now and could use a more defensive approach. I would be grateful for the chance to visit. No sales pitch. Just a conversation and a second set of eyes on the gauges.

Scott Zodin, Keel Wealth Management


This missive is commentary, not individual investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Insights

More Related Articles

Zero G

A New Morning

Why the Price of Oil Matters (It’s Not What You Think)